For the first few years of her education, it was quite apparent that while my Sweetie Pea (4th grade) looooooved and excelled at reading and language arts, she struggled to enjoy and thrive at spelling. There seemed to be a disconnect between her ability to read phonetically and her ability to spell phonetically. This was later confirmed with the results of her mandatory state achievement tests. Although she scored at sxactly grade level for spelling, all her other language skills far exceeded that.
(This post contains affiliate links. Please see my disclosure policy for full details.)
We had been using ABeka Spelling. And although she enjoyed the program in the early years, it was becoming exceedingly obvious that she no longer liked it...or spelling in general, for that matter. Now, I am not one to jump ship on a curriculum simply because a child has a bad attitude about a subject. Sometimes the lesson of perseverance far outweighs the lesson of phonics...or math...or whatever. But, I also wanted to nurture her love of writing and the written word by improving her ability to write correctly with proper spelling.
So after coming upon a few on-line recommendations and a couple of "real life" ones from a few veteran homeschool moms, I made the decision to order All About Spelling's Deluxe Spelling Interactive Kit and Spelling Level 1. Although Level 1 is primarily designed for beginner spellers (think K-5 or first grade), I knew this was going to be a program with a very revolutionary approach to spelling. I did not want her to miss any initial steps by starting out at Level 4. My plan was to quickly work our way through the first couple of levels until she was at or near Level 4 by the end of fourth grade. And then work through Levels 4 and 5 the following year.
Deluxe Spelling Interactive Kit, Level 1 |
All About Spelling is a multi-sensory program based on the Orton-Gillingham approach of learning. As spelling is one of the rare subjects that I do prefer to use a MASTERY approach, All About Spelling seemed like a natural choice. It is phonetically based which provides the skills necessary to be able to spell any word, not just a prescribed list of "age appropriate" ones. Unlike other spelling programs, there are no weekly spelling lists to memorize and no tests to cram for.
Level 1 is broken down into 24 steps. Each step introduces one of the first initial phonetical rules of spelling.
Although the Teacher's Manual does not include or suggest a particular rate at which a child should progress through each lesson, it seems reasonable to assume that on average, a child should have a solid grasp of each step by the end of each week. Because mastery is the goal, you as the teacher, have the luxury of slowing down, or as in our case, speeding up the program to suit the needs of your child.
Letter Tiles |
For the most part, each step consists of a few review suggestions, the new lesson which introduces a new phonetical sound or rule, some words to practice, and a list of reinforcement words for further practice.
Children are encouraged to spell using small magnetic tiles that are color-coded according to the learned rules.
A well-ordered Spelling Review Box is included and is designed to show which sounds, rules, and words a child has mastered, which need to be reviewed, and which have not been learned, at a glance.
What I liked
I certainly can appreciate the fact that my daughter can learn at her own pace. No more worrying about keeping up with a pre-determined format of lessons. She is just wrapping up Level 2 and will be beginning Level 3 by the end of the month.Whereas most spelling programs focus on one list of words per week, All About Spelling has a wonderful review focus. The goal is to learn to spell, not just memorize a list of words for Friday's test only to forget them all by the following Monday. It breaks the process of spelling down into its core elements. Having a set of rules and absolutes helps to make spelling a very black and white subject. Surprisingly, there is a sense of safety and freedom in a boundary. My daughter's confidence level has greatly increased and in turn, so has her ability to spell correctly.
I desire her to be a life-long speller. In order to do that, she has to have a firm grasp of phonetical rules and concepts. That is most definitely a goal of this program.
The New Concept portion of the Teacher's Manual is laid out very clearly. In fact, much of it has verbal suggestions for the teacher to say in order to teach the new rule/sound correctly.
In addition, the program comes with a 100% money-back guarantee and lifetime support via a support forum and an extensive resource center packed with all kinds of helpful tools. Who doesn't love that?!
Level 1 Teacher's Manual |
A few things to consider
Although we used Level 1, my daughter is in the fourth grade and has tested at the national level for fourth-grade spelling. Naturally, Level 1 came easy for her, bolstering her confidence and improving her overall taste for spelling. I look forward to seeing how this progresses as she reaches higher levels and is introduced to more difficult concepts.The review cards come on an 8 1/2 x 11 format with multiple perforated cards to a sheet. These, as well as the magnetic tiles, have to be punched out by hand. This is not ideal, but certainly do-able.
With such a thorough review, the program does take a bit longer to implement each day than I had previously allotted for spelling. (Granted, we are doing one step per day, as opposed to per week in order to zip through the concepts she already knew.) It will be interesting to see how easy/difficult it is to teach four or five different levels of spelling once they begin the program. But, as I have so far been impressed with the outcome, I plan to start my first-grade son at Level 1 next year.
While my daughter is an auditory learner and does not necessarily need the visual and kinesthetic help of letter tiles, I do think they make for a more enjoyable lesson. And, I can definitely see how helpful they would be for other learning styles.
The Nitty-Gritty
All About Spelling Level 1
retails for $29.95
includes the following
includes the following
- a Teacher's Manual
- a Student Packet
Deluxe Spelling Interactive Kit
retails for $49.95
includes the following:
includes the following:
- 108 color-coded 1" letter tiles and divider tiles
- magnets to attach to the letter tiles
- The Basic Phonograms CD-ROM
- spelling review box
- spelling divider cards with tabs
- spelling tote bag
- a set of sparkling bee stickers
We are using AAS Level 1 for my Kindergardener and it's going great! I'm still feeling my way through it, but she is grasping it quickly and I think it will work great for us. It's a neat approach to spelling!
ReplyDeleteI think so, too. And isn't that the whole point of teaching spelling...so that they can actually SPELL!
DeleteI'm so glad to read of someone else trying Level 1 with an older child! I have a 1st grader, but also a 9-year old with mild dyslexia. For her, reading is a struggle, but spelling is a NIGHTMARE! Spelling lists and writing words again and again doesn't help in the least. I just recently began AAS Level 1 with my two children together and am loving it thus far! It seems to be helping my 1st grader grow more confident in his spelling, but I feel the multi-sensory approach is helping my 9-year old segment the words and recognize the individual sounds in ways she's not been able to do until now.
ReplyDeleteOne of the "real life" veteran moms who recommended it to me was a special ed teacher for years and she said if she were to ever go back to teaching in the classroom, this would be the curriculum she would use for Dyslexia and a few other learning struggles.
DeleteWe love AAS! My first grader is on level one. My sister began homeschooling her children this year and started on level one with her 3rd grader so they wouldn't miss anything. I am planning yo use all 7 levels. Excellent review.
ReplyDeleteThanks. And thanks for giving your opinion too. I think it will be helpful for others to know that it's not just me. It really is a good program.
DeleteWe had to change Spelling this year for our younger two for the same reason. I chose AAS because of the importance of learning the phonics rules and the great reviews I read for struggling spellers. It has worked out great for us.
ReplyDeleteI am so glad to have read this! I have been contemplating a chance to AAS for my 5th grader (struggles like crazy with spelling) and my first grader, but have been hesitant due to the higher cost. I feel more confident after reading the review and the comments, so thanks!
ReplyDeleteGlad the review helped. Good luck with whatever you choose! AAS certainly isn't for everyone, but we've really liked it and will be using it with our three oldest next year...each at their own individual level.
DeleteDoes each individual child need his/her own box for the cards? If not, how do you keep track of who has mastered what card?
ReplyDeleteHeather I have not used this program yet. I am def getting it for my 3 boys next year. I have read from some other reviews to use different colored paper clips to keep track of all the kids. :)
ReplyDeleteHow big of a board do you feel that you need? They recommend 2'x3' but I wonder if it could be effective with something smaller. Thanks.
ReplyDeleteI didn't have room for another board, so I am using the front of my metal storage cabinet. You need room to leave all of the tiles up in a certain order and room to pull them into the middle to spell. The main letters probably do take up almost 3 feet. I have read of some that don't hang the board and store behind a cabinet or bookshelf when not in use.
DeleteThat's actually what we do. I stick the board behind a cabinet in my dining room. Every now and then some of the tiles fall off when I move the board, but not often.
DeleteThank you for sharing your experience! My oldest has had a very difficult time grasping spelling for many reasons. We are zipping through level 1 and hope to start level 2 soon. Grateful for a program that is working well. We've tried many.
ReplyDeleteI’m. a homeschooling mom, and I use all about reading and spelling. I’m pleased with the results of the program. I really think I will be using all about reading and spelling for many years to come.
DeleteYou're welcome. AAS is definitely a program that you won't see immediate results with because of the methods it uses. It's a for-the-long-haul kind of curriculum. Stick with it to the end. I'm so glad I did!
ReplyDeleteHI, I am curious to hear how AAS went over the years for your family since the original review was posted by you. Up to which grade/s did you use this program? I would like to try this with my children as well as my oldest could use some help (8th grade). Thank you.
ReplyDeleteMy daughter went all the way through the program and my boys are making their way to the end. You can read more about how we liked the full 7 level program here>>>
Deletehttps://www.theunlikelyhomeschool.com/2017/02/3-ways-spelling.html
I realize this is an older post, but it is such an encouragement to me. My daughter is in 3rd-ish grad. ha Thank you. Signed, Mama battling the ghost of public school past ha
ReplyDeleteHi! So glad I found this review and comment thread. My son is in 4th grade but struggles tremendously with spelling simple words and I know that most of it stems from lack of confidence. He thinks he'll mess up, therefore he does... I just received AAS levels 1 and 2, we're starting tomorrow. I'm feeling confident this will be a turning point for him.
ReplyDeleteThank you for this post :)
Does this program cover phonics too?
ReplyDeleteI am currently using Phonic Zoo with my daughter, which has been going well. It does teach spelling rules but I find she doesn’t apply the rules when she spells. She does well on her spelling test but then I catch her spelling words she has learned incorrectly in her daily writing. She is currently in 5th grade. I see the program really wants them to start at level 1. I am concerned she will hate it if she thinks it is too “babyish”. Thoughts?
ReplyDeleteStarting at level 1 is important. That said, she'll probably fly right through it. Don't be afraid to do several sections a day. My daughter started from the beginning in 4th grade and while that meant she didn't finish book 7 until high school, she was a much better spelling for it. And isn't that the point? The numbers on the front aren't designed to follow grade levels necessarily, but skill levels.
DeleteI'm in the same boat with a young 4th grader who struggles with spelling. The cost is a big factor, but this is probably what we should have started with. Off we go!
ReplyDelete